Im sorry,
But I really am SOOO cynical of the so called top ten agents. I can say that there are many West End working actors, in straight AND musical theatre who are iwth a variety of agents.
I think its far more balanced to say that an agent who is right for YOU, and who has good contacts. There are many of them out there, and I can even say that my agent got one of her clients into Amys View in the West End. They are not one of the so called "top 10" that has been mentioned but they get all the auditions and breakdowns etc, and are warm and totally aproachable.
This is why I just wonder if its simply a way of feeding into a defeatist attitude. I fully fully agree that there are some utterly CRAP CRAP CRAP agents out there, and they can wreck a persons career and emotional sanity by the way they behave( I am being totally literal- I have seen this happen), but i also knwo that there are many many stable , trustworthy, and humane agents who constantly get their clients good auditions.
I have a friend who is from South Africa. While I was training in drama achool, he was touted in Johannesburg and was HUGE. he did Hamlet, Julius caesar etc, he has also worked in the National and various places in the UK.
He was treated abysmally by a high powered agent NOT on the top ten list, and struggled to get a new agent. He finally found one that is also VERY prestigious that is NOT on the list above either,
All he has done is sit on their books!!! He has a fabulous CV, he has an established number of roles and is probably one of the best South African actors of his generation. I mean this. He knows his onions. he has now gone back to SA to have a small break.
What i am saying is that even a highly experienced actor with great credits and a good reputation found a high profile agent to be a waste of time.
I am just saying that there is so much more to this than a magic agent, and I have learnt the hard way that all an agent can do is push you to a certain degree, rely on their contacts and past reputation and just keep promoting you. If we always blame our agents etc, surely we are becoming victims???
In a way, when a client of theirs gets a job, we should rejoice because it means the agency is taken more seriously and casting directors will be more willing to use the agency again.
But being realistic on the other side, CDs are difficult and sometimes unwilling to change, but I think I have personally learnt to trust my instincts more nowadays.
If my gut tells me I am asking for trouble, I tend to take it more seriously, as many people have made weird and wonderful promises and nothing has happened.
My agent said simply " I cant promise we can do any better than your previous agents, but we will try to do the best we can for you" after they accepted me.
That is humble, humane and totally full of integrity and this is what I think its got to be about ultimately.